Skip to content

Reading 03 · GE

The tax on parts looked like a fixed cost.

Imported after-sales parts carried a heavy tax bill, and everyone treated it as a cost of doing business. Reviewing the tax classification cut more than US$20 million a year.

Import duty went into the cost of every part as if it were fixed.

From import to after-sales cost

  1. Imported part

    To keep the equipment running

  2. Tax classification

    The NCM code of each part

  3. Import duty

    High, seen as a cost of doing business

  4. After-sales cost

    Treated as fixed

Source: GE, medical equipment after-sales in Brazil.
01

Method stage: Problem

What looked like the problem

Imported parts were expensive, and that was seen as a cost of doing business: import duties are high in Brazil, period.

02

Method stage: Evidence

What evidence I would look for

The tax classification (NCM, Brazil's customs code) of each part, how much tax it paid and whether the classification matched what the part actually was. I started with the parts carrying the biggest tax bill and checked them line by line. Our regional senior support engineers helped identify what each part was in the equipment (MRI, CT, PET-CT, X-ray, ultrasound), and tax specialists validated the classification.

03

Method stage: Evidence

What the evidence showed

Some items were misclassified. Accessories that were already tax-exempt were being treated as IT equipment, taxed at over 18%. And parts with no local production were still paying a tax that could be challenged.

04

Method stage: Problem

What the real problem was

Tax on parts was treated as a given. Nobody reviewed the classification after the item was set up, so the error repeated with every import.

05

Method stage: Decision

What I would decide first

Two workstreams: correct the classification of the misclassified items and petition Brazil's trade ministry (MDIC) to exempt or reduce the tax on parts with no local production. The result was more than US$20 million a year in savings.

What it looked like

Imported parts were expensive, and that was seen as a cost of doing business: import duties are high in Brazil, period.

Root cause

Tax on parts was treated as a given.

Decision

Two workstreams: correct the classification of the misclassified items and petition Brazil's trade ministry (MDIC) to exempt or reduce the tax on parts with no local production.

What changed · Tax on imported parts

Beforetreated as a fixed cost
Aftermore than US$ 20 million a year in savings

Do this tomorrow

Take the 10 imported items with the biggest tax bill and have someone who knows each item check whether its tax classification matches what it actually is.

Other readings

Next reading · coming soon