Guide · Decision and evidence
How to tell if your 2027 plan is a strategy or a list of goals
A 6-step test, drawn from Richard Rumelt, to see whether next year's plan solves a problem or just promises a number.
A plan only becomes a strategy when it has a diagnosis and a choice.
The two tests that separate a strategy from a list of goals
- A bet.
- Strategy.
- List of goals.
- Diagnosis on the shelf.
The question
Between October and December, many leadership teams put together next year’s plan. The document usually has a mission, a vision, a revenue target and a list of initiatives, one or two per department. What problem does that plan solve? If nobody can answer in one sentence, what you have is a list of goals.
Richard Rumelt, a strategy professor at UCLA, put a name to this in Good Strategy/Bad Strategy, published in 2011. In his view, bad strategy has four hallmarks: inflated words posing as concepts, no defined obstacle, goals in place of strategy, and objectives that miss what matters or that nobody can deliver. The planning template with vision, mission, values and initiatives is, in his account, one of the most common ways to end up there.
Growing 20% is a goal. The strategy is what the company will do differently to get there, given what stands in the way. Rumelt calls the three parts every strategy needs its kernel.
A strategy has three parts, and the goal is none of them.
The kernel of strategy, according to Richard Rumelt
Diagnosis
What the main obstacle is
Guiding policy
How the company will deal with it
Coherent actions
What gets done, with which resources, each one reinforcing the others
When to use it
Before you lock in the 2027 plan and budget. Also when this year’s plan reached October with most initiatives half done, or when each executive describes a different priority for the same company.
Step by step
- Write the diagnosis before any goal. In 3 or 4 sentences, say what’s keeping the company from going further next year. “Fierce competition” doesn’t work, because it applies to any company. “We lose the large orders because our delivery time is twice the competitor’s” works. To get to that sentence, use evidence rather than impressions: the deals lost this year and the reason for each, margin by product line in the income statement, what the customers who stopped buying said.
- Test every goal against the diagnosis. For each number in the plan, ask which obstacle it addresses. A goal that doesn’t connect to the diagnosis is a wish. It can stay in the plan, but it doesn’t count as strategy.
- Choose the guiding policy. It’s one sentence that says how the company will deal with the obstacle: the direction, without the details. “We’ll separate simple orders from complex ones and deliver the simple ones within a week” is a policy. It guides decisions made by people who weren’t in the room.
- Write down what’s out. Every choice leaves things out: a market, a product, an initiative someone was pushing. Rumelt points to the difficulty of choosing as the reason there’s so much bad strategy, because it’s easier to include every department’s request than to say no to an executive. If the list of what’s out is empty, no choice was made.
- Check that the actions reinforce each other. Coherent actions are the third part of the kernel. Each action has to fit the budget, have people to carry it out and help the others along. Two initiatives competing for the same people in the same quarter get in each other’s way.
- Give every action an owner, a metric and a cadence. This is the part plans tend to forget, and it decides whether the plan leaves the page. Each action has one person who answers for it, one number that shows whether it’s moving and one meeting where that number comes up every week or every month.
The plan that saved Apple had no revenue target.
Rumelt opens the book with Steve Jobs’s return to Apple. In September 1997, by his account, the company was two months from bankruptcy. The market expected a growth plan: new products, a big partner, an ambitious target. Jobs didn’t announce any revenue or profit goal.
The diagnosis was simple to state and hard to accept. Apple was trying to cover the entire personal computer market with the size of a niche manufacturer. The guiding policy followed from it: shrink the company down to a core that could survive. And the actions all pointed the same way, each one reinforcing the others.
In one year, Apple cut whatever didn't fit the strategy.
Before and after Steve Jobs's return, in number of items
Portables came down to a single laptop. Printers and other peripherals were dropped. Manufacturing moved to Taiwan, and inventory fell by more than 80%. An online store started selling directly to consumers. Jobs also persuaded Microsoft to invest US$150 million in Apple and to keep Office on the company’s computers.
The result showed up in the financials. In fiscal 1997, Apple lost nearly US$1.05 billion. In fiscal 1998, it earned US$309 million, according to The New York Times in October 1998. For Rumelt, the plan’s strength lay in going after the central problem with coordinated actions. Cutting without a criterion would have shrunk the company without saving it.
A mid-sized company isn’t going to cut 14 of its 15 products. The lesson that applies is the chain of reasoning: the diagnosis sets the policy, and the policy explains every cut. Without the diagnosis, the same cuts would have looked like desperation.
The most common mistake
Building the plan by adding up each department’s requests. Sales wants more reps, marketing wants more budget, operations wants a new system, and the plan stacks it all up with a growth target on top. What comes out is a budget, not a strategy, because no problem was chosen and nothing was left out.
The cost of that shows up mid-year, when each person picks the priority they want to follow.
The people executing the plan rarely know what the goal is.
Employees in the authors' initial survey, in %
With a long list of priorities, scattered effort is the predictable result. A plan with one diagnosis, one policy and a few actions is easier to remember, and easier to hold people to.
Do this tomorrow
Open your 2027 plan, or the draft of it, and write down on a sheet of paper, in one sentence, the main problem it solves. If the sentence won't come, or if all it says is "grow," the diagnosis hasn't been done yet.